FRCMFD Paper – Technical Evaluation
FRCMFD Paper – Technical Evaluation 1. Global logical consistency Null hypothesis: γ independent of baryonic and environmental variables is clearly stated and consistently used. Sample sizes: 171 γ fits, 136 with environment (v1.0), 104 (v1.1b), 80 (v1.2) are used consistently across sections and tables. Versioning: v1.0 (raw γ), v1.1b (log Vflat + log L[3.6]), v1.2 (log Vflat + log L[3.6] + log SFR) is consistently described in text, tables, and appendices. No internal contradictions were found between the numerical results in the tables and the narrative summary. 2. Mathematics and statistics 2.1 Rotation curve model and regularization The interpolation formula for V(R) is mathematically well-defined and smooth for γ > 0. The log-normal regularization term R(γ) and total objective L total are correctly specified and dimensionally consistent. The statement that the model “asymptotes to a constant at large R” is correct; the qualif...