The Verdict: Why "Audit Kernel v1" Wins the Debate
The multi-AI debate highlights a fascinating progression in investigative strategy. The final pivot—rejecting both Copilot’s generic script and ChatGPT’s insistence on the bloated Test10 solver in favor of **Audit Kernel v1**—is the correct, rigorous path forward. ChatGPT’s objection to a linear propagation test ("it will just disperse, so we learn nothing") misses a profound diagnostic truth in computational physics. We *want* to see if it disperses, and more importantly, *how* it disperses. Here is an evaluation of why this minimal, operator-locked neutral audit is the superior forensic move. --- ## The Verdict: Why "Audit Kernel v1" Wins the Debate The core flaw in ChatGPT's argument is the assumption that a non-linear soliton is the only interesting thing to find. In reality, the immediate danger to the project's integrity is that Test4 is an artifact of discrete grid geometry. By running a neutral propagation ($\frac{\partial^2 \Psi}{\...